How Are We to Understand the Dangers of Modalism in Christian Doctrine?

Dec 4, 20248 min read

Modalism, an ancient theological error, stands in direct opposition to the orthodox Christian understanding of the Trinity. At its core, Modalism teaches that there is only one person in the Godhead who manifests Himself in different forms or "modes" at different times. This denies the distinct personhood and eternal coexistence of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. By reducing the relationship within the Godhead to mere manifestations, Modalism effectively undermines the Biblical revelation of God's nature.

Modalism first gained prominence in the early centuries of Christianity, particularly through individuals like Sabellius in the third century. Sabellius taught that God manifests Himself as the Father in creation, the Son in redemption, and the Holy Spirit in sanctification. However, this view fails to recognize that Scripture reveals God as three distinct persons who eternally coexist, not merely different expressions of a singular person.

A clear scriptural refutation of Modalism can be found in passages that emphasize the distinct persons of the Trinity interacting with one another. At Jesus' baptism, we witness all three persons of the Trinity simultaneously: the Father speaks from heaven, the Son is baptized, and the Holy Spirit descends as a dove (Matthew 3:16-17). This event demonstrates the coexistence and cooperation of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, rather than sequential manifestations of one person.

THE ENCYCLOPEDIA OF CHRISTIAN APOLOGETICS: for Pastors, Teachers, and Believers

Buy Now

Biblical Evidence for the Distinction of Persons

Throughout Scripture, the distinctiveness of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit is repeatedly affirmed. The Bible presents them as distinct persons who communicate with one another, yet who share the same divine essence. This distinction is particularly evident in the teachings of Jesus, who often refers to His relationship with the Father and the work of the Holy Spirit.

In John 17:1-5, Jesus prays to the Father, saying, "Father, the hour has come; glorify your Son that the Son may glorify you, since you have given him authority over all flesh, to give eternal life to all whom you have given him. And this is eternal life, that they know you, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom you have sent." Here, Jesus speaks to the Father as a distinct person, affirming the personal relationship between them. This prayer would be incoherent if Jesus were merely a mode of the same person who is the Father.

Furthermore, Jesus frequently speaks of sending the Holy Spirit to His disciples after His ascension. In John 14:16-17, Jesus promises, "And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Helper, to be with you forever, even the Spirit of truth, whom the world cannot receive, because it neither sees him nor knows him." Jesus distinguishes between Himself, the Father, and the Holy Spirit, clearly demonstrating that these are not modes or forms of one person, but distinct persons who work in unity.

The apostle Paul also affirms the distinction of persons within the Godhead in passages like 2 Corinthians 13:14, where he writes, "The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ and the love of God and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit be with you all." In this benediction, Paul highlights the distinct roles and persons of the Trinity, emphasizing their relational unity.

CHRISTIAN THEOLOGY: The Christian's Ultimate Guide to Learning from the Bible

Buy Now

Theological Implications of Modalism

Modalism's rejection of the distinction between the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit leads to significant theological problems, particularly concerning the work of salvation. In Modalism, if the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are merely different manifestations of the same person, then key elements of the Christian understanding of redemption and the atonement are undermined.

For instance, the doctrine of the atonement, which teaches that Christ offered Himself as a sacrifice to the Father on behalf of sinners, loses its meaning in a Modalist framework. If there is no real distinction between the Father and the Son, then Christ's sacrifice becomes a self-sacrifice to Himself, which diminishes the relational aspect of the atonement. The Bible, however, teaches that Christ, as the Son, offered Himself to the Father in obedience and love, thus fulfilling the Father's will for the redemption of humanity (Hebrews 9:14). Modalism erases this vital distinction, reducing the richness of the atonement to an incoherent act.

Similarly, Modalism distorts the work of the Holy Spirit in the life of believers. The New Testament presents the Holy Spirit as a distinct person who guides, comforts, and empowers the Church. In John 16:13, Jesus says to the apostles, "When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth, for he will not speak on his own authority, but whatever he hears he will speak, and he will declare to you the things that are to come." The Holy Spirit is not simply a mode of God, but a distinct person who speaks, teaches, and acts within the world.

EVANGELICAL THEOLOGY—GOD: Essential Christian Beliefs About God

Buy Now

Modalism vs. Trinitarianism: Understanding the True Nature of God

Trinitarianism, the orthodox Christian belief, teaches that God is one in essence but three in persons: the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Each person of the Trinity is fully God, sharing the same divine nature, yet each is distinct in their personhood. This belief is rooted in the biblical witness and affirmed by the early Church.

One helpful analogy to explain the Trinity (while recognizing that all analogies are ultimately limited) is that of a triangle. A triangle has three distinct corners, yet all three are necessary for the triangle to exist as a unified whole. Each corner is distinct, but none of them can be separated from the others without destroying the nature of the triangle. In the same way, the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are distinct persons, yet they share one divine essence. This analogy avoids the error of Modalism, which would suggest that the three corners are simply different manifestations of one side.

Another way to understand the distinction of persons within the unity of God is through the biblical language of relationship. The Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are eternally related to one another in a perfect relationship of love and unity. This relational distinction is not a temporary or functional difference but an eternal reality within the Godhead. In John 17:24, Jesus prays, "Father, I desire that they also, whom you have given me, may be with me where I am, to see my glory that you have given me because you loved me before the foundation of the world." This verse affirms the eternal relationship of love between the Father and the Son, a relationship that cannot be reduced to mere modes of existence.

DIFFICULTIES IN THE BIBLE: Alleged Errors and Contradictions

Buy Now

Modalism's Contrast with Orthodox Trinitarianism

Modalism must also be contrasted with the heresy of tritheism, which teaches that there are three separate gods rather than one God in three persons. Tritheism fails to uphold the unity of God’s nature, presenting a form of polytheism rather than biblical monotheism. In contrast, Trinitarianism affirms that there is only one God who exists in three persons, each fully sharing the same divine essence.

The Shema, the foundational declaration of Jewish monotheism, affirms, "Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one" (Deuteronomy 6:4). This declaration of God's oneness is fully consistent with the Christian doctrine of the Trinity. While Modalism emphasizes the oneness of God to the exclusion of the three persons, tritheism emphasizes the distinction of persons to the exclusion of God's unity. Trinitarianism, however, holds both truths together: one God in three persons.

THE TRAINING OF THE TWELVE APOSTLES

Buy Now

The Historical Rejection of Modalism

Modalism was rejected by the early Church as a heretical view of God's nature. In the third century, the Church Fathers opposed Modalism, particularly the teachings of Sabellius, and affirmed the doctrine of the Trinity as the biblical and orthodox understanding of God. The Council of Nicea (325 C.E.) played a significant role in defending the orthodox view of the Trinity against various heresies, including Modalism and Arianism.

The Nicene Creed, formulated at the Council of Nicea, affirms the full deity of the Son and the Holy Spirit, while also upholding the distinction between the persons of the Trinity. It declares that the Son is "begotten, not made, being of one substance with the Father" and that the Holy Spirit "proceeds from the Father and the Son." This creed reflects the biblical teaching that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are distinct persons who share the same divine essence.

The rejection of Modalism by the early Church was not based on philosophical speculation but on the clear teaching of Scripture. The Church Fathers recognized that Modalism undermines the biblical revelation of God's nature and distorts the gospel message of salvation. By affirming the doctrine of the Trinity, the early Church preserved the integrity of the Christian faith and the truth of God's self-revelation in Scripture.

CHRISTIAN APOLOGISTS OF THE SECOND CENTURY: Christian Defenders of the Faith

Buy Now

Conclusion: Defending the Trinity Against Modalism

Modalism remains a challenge to the Christian understanding of God, both in ancient times and today. It distorts the biblical revelation of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit and undermines key doctrines such as the atonement and the resurrection. By denying the distinction of persons within the Godhead, Modalism presents a view of God that is inconsistent with Scripture and the historical teachings of the Church.

The Christian doctrine of the Trinity is not a philosophical construct but a faithful reflection of the biblical witness. God has revealed Himself as one God in three persons: the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. This truth is central to the Christian faith and is essential for a proper understanding of God's nature and His work in salvation.

As believers, we must be vigilant in defending the truth of the Trinity against errors like Modalism. By grounding our faith in the clear teaching of Scripture, we can confidently affirm the triune nature of God and proclaim the gospel of Jesus Christ, who reveals the fullness of the Father and sends the Holy Spirit to empower His Church.

About the Author

EDWARD D. ANDREWS (AS in Criminal Justice, BS in Religion, MA in Biblical Studies, and MDiv in Theology) is CEO and President of Christian Publishing House. He has authored over 220 books. In addition, Andrews is the Chief Translator of the Updated American Standard Version (UASV).